10 Reasons to Believe in the Resurrection


10 Reasons to Believe the Resurrection

How many reasons can you list?

St Paul said that if Christ did not rise from the dead we are the greatest of fools. But if Jesus did rise from the dead everyone else could be considered the greatest of fools. Now Easter is over, I thought it appropriate to present 10 reasons why the resurrection happened.

10. If the Apostles made it up, they would have arrived before the women.  In first century Israel a women’s testimony did not have the value of law. Anyone wanting to fake it would have legitimate witnesses, men, there first.

9. The Apostles are transformed by it. By their own accounts, they all go into hiding after the crucifixion but somehow a month and a half later, St. Peter appears in public and proclaims it using words that would get him killed if not true. The resurrection is the only logical explanation.

8. If the Apostles stole the body, somebody would have found it. Many in Jerusalem were against them and would have looked for the body to discredit them, remember how the Sanhedrin pays the guards to say the apostles stole it. The apostles message couldn’t have survived 10 minutes if someone displayed the dead body.

7. St Paul has a memorized and received formula by 50AD. Most scholars put the First Letter to the Corinthians around 50AD but St Paul states a formula he had received and previously passed on to the Corinthians that clearly expresses resurrection faith (15:3-8). Obviously the resurrection wasn’t invented decades later.

6. Myths always develop later. Hindus and others have the mythical presence of the gods in history but this is either in pre-history or millennia before. Buddhists have myths about Buddha but these were first written over 500 years after Buddha. No religion is known to make up historical myths to which the original authors claim to be eyewitnesses.

5. The evangelists don’t stick to a story. When a group of people make up a story, they make sure they all say exactly the same thing, but the four Gospel accounts seem hard to harmonize exactly so they refer to real memories which tend to vary a little in the details.

4. The history of Christianity. Who would have thought that in 70 years Churches would be founded in every major city on the Mediterranean and in 300 years it would be the official religion? Without the truth of the resurrection, it makes no sense.

3. The soldiers were professionals. Some claim Jesus was just very weak but professional Roman soldiers confirmed death then jabbed a spear through his heart to confirm it.

2. His enemies confirm his identity on the cross. If someone other than Jesus was crucified, the mockers would have realized. Jesus really died.

1. Nobody would go to death for something he made up. 11 of the 12 apostles were put to death for their belief in the resurrection; if they made it up, at least one would have recanted and told where they hid the body.

Bonus: It really happened and we can share in it. This is the reason above and beyond all the other reasons. Faith, not just reason and history.

Teens need to experience Christ. I am a Catholic religious priest with the Legion of Christ who tries to help them do that. Part of doing that is running this blog. Currently I'm stationed in the DC Metro area preparing material for RCSpirituality.org (Regnum Christi Spirituality Center), studying an advanced Theology degree, and helping youth ministry freelance. If you need help with your youth ministry, such as retreats, talks, programs, volunteer training or consultation, contact me via Twitter or Facebook. You can buy my book Spiritually Mentoring Teenage Boys in paperback or on Kindle.


Pokemon or Old Testament – Catholic Youth Ministry Screen Game

3 Comments

  1. Manny

    Father, This was excellent. Your number 8 (the second one, you have two number 8’s) is the most convincing to me.

    Reply
    • Matthew P. Schneider, LC

      I fixed the 2 number 8s. I renumbered all the way down and made the former #1 a bonus.

      Reply
  2. 5th

    unfortunately, having human “experience” as an argument doesnt do much….
    just a few decades ago, Charles Manson had his “Family”, Jonestown happened… and even today, you have TV evangelists and healers. – people choose to believe those things.
    Imagine how gullible people 2000 years ago would have been.

    and only reason people believe it had happened is tradiiton and because they were brought up that way.

    Reply

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Think Pope Francis Is Squishy? Think Again - BigPulpit.com - […] Russell Shaw, Aleteia Strong Rebuttal to Metropolitan Hilarion’s Offensive Remarks – Byz Ed. 10 Reasons to Believe in the…
  2. 10 reasons you should believe in the Resurrection of Jesus... - Christian Forums - […] happened. For instance: If the Apostles made it up, they would have arrived before the women. 10…

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

thrive-logo-black

Try Out Our New Online Membership Community for Free!

Click the button below to find out more about Thrive and claim your invite to a free trial of the new community created exclusively for Catholic youth ministers.

CLICK HERE

You have Successfully Subscribed!